CALL US NOW

Sell Coins (We Buy Gold, Silver & Rare Coins)

Sell Coin Service in Pittsburgh – Pittsburgh Coin Buyers

At Pittsburgh Coin Buyers, we provide a transparent, fair, and professional coin-selling experience for residents across Pittsburgh, PA. Whether you inherited a coin collection, want to liquidate investment assets, or simply have a few coins to cash in, our experts are ready to assist.

We buy gold coins, silver rounds, rare collectibles, certified coins, and more—offering competitive prices based on real-time market rates and numismatic value. With decades of experience and a reputation built on integrity, Pittsburgh Coin Buyers is your trusted partner for selling coins locally.

Why Sell Your Coins to Us?

Selling coins can be intimidating, especially if you don’t know what they’re worth or how the process works. Here’s why Pittsburgh Coin Buyers is the best choice in Pittsburgh:

  1. Top Dollar Offers: We base offers on spot metal prices, demand, and numismatic premium—ensuring you get the highest value.

  2. Free Evaluations: No obligation to sell. We provide accurate, professional appraisals at no cost.

  3. Immediate Payment: Walk out with cash or check the same day you accept our offer.

  4. Local & Trusted: We’re a community-based business with strong roots in Pittsburgh. No mail-ins. No waiting.

  5. Certified Professionals: Our staff includes trained numismatists who understand the true worth of collectible and bullion coins.

  6. No Pressure: We’re here to educate, not pressure. You can sell, hold, or just get informed.

Our mission is to empower every seller with knowledge, fair pricing, and a smooth transaction.

What Types of Coins Do We Buy?

We purchase a broad spectrum of coins, from historic rarities to modern bullion. Here are the main categories:

1. U.S. Gold Coins

  • Pre-1933 U.S. Gold (Liberty Head, Saint-Gaudens)

  • American Gold Eagles

  • Gold Buffalo Coins

2. Foreign Gold Coins

  • British Sovereigns

  • South African Krugerrands

  • Canadian Maple Leafs

  • Mexican 50 Pesos

3. Silver Coins

  • American Silver Eagles

  • Morgan & Peace Silver Dollars

  • Junk Silver (90% U.S. Coins)

  • Silver Rounds and Bars

4. Rare and Collectible Coins

  • Key Date Coins

  • Mint Errors

  • Obsolete Currency

  • Commemorative Issues

5. Certified Coins

  • PCGS and NGC Slabbed Coins

  • CAC Endorsed Coins

6. Coin Collections

  • Estate Coin Collections

  • Accumulated Holdings

  • Inherited Assets

7. Bullion Products

  • Silver Bars (1 oz to 100 oz)

  • Gold Bars (gram to kilo)

  • Platinum and Palladium Coins

If you’re unsure what you have, bring it in. We evaluate and buy coins in any condition, even heavily circulated or tarnished.

Factors That Determine the Value of Your Coins

Knowing what drives coin value can help you make smarter selling decisions. Here are the main factors we use to evaluate your items:

1. Metal Content

Gold, silver, platinum, and palladium coins have intrinsic value based on current spot prices. The purity (e.g., .999 fine silver) also matters.

2. Condition (Grading)

Using the Sheldon Scale (1 to 70), condition plays a major role. Higher-grade coins bring significantly more value, especially when uncirculated or proof.

3. Rarity

Low mintage coins or those with surviving scarcity due to historical events (like melting or hoarding) command collector premiums.

4. Demand

Coins tied to historical significance, popular series, or high collector interest will fetch higher prices.

5. Certification

Grading from third-party agencies like PCGS or NGC ensures authenticity and often boosts market confidence and value.

6. Market Trends

We assess current collector demand, bullion market trends, and recent sales data to determine fair and competitive offers.

We combine real-time pricing data with decades of hands-on numismatic experience to deliver precision and fairness.

Frequently Asked Questions

Our experts provide free, accurate assessments based on condition, rarity, metal content, and market demand. You’ll receive a verbal appraisal on-site and can request a written report if needed.

No. Cleaning coins can reduce their value by removing original surfaces. Bring them as-is. We appreciate natural condition and patina.

Absolutely. We buy all types of coins—common, worn, or tarnished. Many still hold value from metal content alone.

We’ll evaluate your entire collection and make offers on all coins we can purchase. If some items aren’t sellable, we’ll explain why.

Yes. Our Pittsburgh location is secure and private. We offer discrete evaluations and immediate payment for your safety and convenience.

Contact Us Today!

If you’re ready to sell your coins, Pittsburgh Coin Buyers offers the most trusted, transparent, and competitive service in the area.

Bring your coins, get a fair offer, and walk out with cash. Whether you’re selling a single coin or a multi-generational collection, Pittsburgh Coin Buyers is the name Pittsburgh trusts.

Contact Now